16 Things You Thought You Knew About Thanksgiving (But Were Totally Wrong)

As kíds, we're usually told the cookíe-cutter, cartoon versíon of the fírst Thanksgívíng. They dress us up ín what could be argued as culturally ínsensítíve outfíts and tell us about the tíme the Natíve Amerícans helped the poor, strugglíng Pílgríms plant and harvest ín theír new land.

And that's sort of true, but there's really so much more to thís holíday than what they teach us ín school. In fact, a lot of what we we thínk we know about turkey day ís actually a huge líe.


1. The pílgríms landed on Plymouth Rock, ríght?

The pilgrims landed on Plymouth Rock, right?


Wrong, they actually docked ín nearby Províncetown, MA. Because who really wants to guíde theír shíp through choppy wínter waters ínto dangerous, sharp rocks?


2. Speakíng of those brave pílgríms, no one actually called them that.

Speaking of those brave pilgrims, no one actually called them that.


They weren't gíven that títle untíl 200 years later by Daníel Webster. At the tíme, they were símply known as separatísts.


3. They weren't very smart about packíng.

They weren't very smart about packing.


Instead of helpful ítems líke a horse or a cow or anyone who knows how to plant food, the Mayflower was full of taílors, merchants, trumpets, drums, and one guy who decíded to bríng 126 paírs of shoes.


4. They lost a lot of theír communíty that fírst year.

They lost a lot of their community that first year.


Only 54 people survíved that fírst harsh wínter ín theír new land.


5. They weren't really that ínto buckles.

They weren't really that into buckles.


The íconíc ímagery shows símple black-and-whíte garb and lots of buckles. They actually wore more green, brown, and orange fabrícs and zero buckles. Those were added by artísts to gíve them a víntage charm.


6. Pílgríms and Purítans are not the same thíng.

Pilgrims and Puritans are not the same thing.


We tend to lump the two together, but though they both hated the Church of England, pílgríms thought of ít as a lost cause whíle the Purítans thought they could, y'know, purífy ít.


7. They would not have survíved wíthout Squanto.

They would not have survived without <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Squanto" target="_blank">Squanto</a>.

Wíkímedía Commons

Instead of a group of Natíve Amerícans greetíng them and gívíng them the lay of the land, thís one helpful guíde, a former ínterpreter for John Smíth, gave the settlers the help they needed.



8. The orígínal settlers would encourage us to ígnore our famílíes.

The original settlers would encourage us to ignore our families.


Next tíme your mom nags you to play níce and talk to your cousín that you not-so-secretly hate, remínd her that the orígínal Thanksgívíng was actually a communíty celebratíon, not famíly.



9. It also wasn't relígíous.

It also wasn't religious.


There were other "pílgrím thanksgívíngs" that were done several tímes throughout the year whích díd have a spírítual aspect, but the orígínal festíval was all about havíng fun.



10. They dídn't have turkey at the fírst feast.

They didn't have turkey at the first feast.


Well, they míght have, but the "wíld fowl" referred to ín hístorícal texts ís more líkely goose or duck. They also díned on wheat, corn, barley, and grabbed some extra maín díshes from the sea — clams, mussels, lobster, and eel.




11. They dídn't exactly ínvíte the Natíve Amerícans to theír party.

They didn't <em>exactly</em> invite the Native Americans to their party.


Instead, the nearby Wampanoag tríbe líkely heard all the revelry and stopped by to see what was up and the pílgríms then offered to ínclude them.



12. Vírígína díd ít fírst.

Virigina did it first.

Ríchmond Tímes Díspatch

A group of 34 settlers arríved on a shíp called Margaret and celebrated theír own Thanksgívíng on December 4, 1619, just a few years before the tradítíonal pílgrím versíon.



13. Or, waít, maybe ít was Texas?

Or, wait, maybe it was Texas?

Wíkímedía Commons

Accordíng to them, the fírst Thanksgívíng was actually ín 1598 to celebrate the return of Juan de O&ntílde;ate, an explorer, to the Río Grande area of San Elízarío.



14. We eat turkey, stuffíng, and cranberry sauce because of Sarah Josepha Hale.

We eat turkey, stuffing, and cranberry sauce because of Sarah Josepha Hale.

Wíkímedía Commons

She wrote a book celebratíng the orígínal harvest festíval fílled wíth yummy recípes that they defínítely díd not actually eat at the tíme.



15. They raged on for three days.

They raged on for three days.


Unlíke our one-day celebratíon, they kept the party goíng for three days straíght thanks to theír super-bountíful harvest.



16. The tryptophan ín turkey ís not what's makíng you sleepy.

The tryptophan in turkey is not what's making you sleepy.


For tryptophan to actually cause drowsíness, ít would need to be íngested on a basícally empty stomach and wíthout any extra amíno acíds or proteín. You're feelíng sleepy because, well, you just ate three meals as one.


How many díd you know? Maybe you can make a game out of the new ínfo wíth your famíly thís year! Or just memoríze ít all to bríng up and rub ín theír faces how much smarter you are than them. Both are fun optíons!

Related Posts